Choose the period and common assumptions
Write down the existing balance, rate, payment schedule and remaining amortization. For the proposed mortgage, separate extra borrowing from the amount replacing the current loan. Choose a comparison date, such as the existing term’s maturity or an intended sale. State any assumed future rate rather than presenting it as known. When the options involve different loan amounts or repayment periods, the comparison needs to explain how those differences affect the result.
Include costs and the ending balance
Add the existing lender’s payout charges and the new loan’s applicable setup costs. Estimate payments and the amount still owing at the comparison date for both options. A lower monthly payment can accompany slower principal repayment, which affects the overall outcome. Use the same treatment for fees paid from savings and fees added to borrowing. I can help organise a worksheet that makes those assumptions visible and identifies which figures need confirmation.
Treat the quick calculation as a screening step
For a simple cash-flow illustration, $6,000 in upfront costs divided by a $200 monthly payment reduction equals 30 months. That calculation ignores differences in principal repayment, interest on financed fees and rate changes, so it cannot establish total savings. Use it to decide what deserves a fuller review. Test a shorter holding period as well. A planned move or another refinance may occur before an apparent benefit has had time to cover the transaction costs.
Prepare for the conversation
- Choose one comparison date for both options.
- Separate new cash borrowing from mortgage replacement.
- Include setup costs, payments and remaining balances.
- Test an earlier sale or another financing change.
Start with a summary of your situation. I’ll explain how to share supporting documents securely when they are needed.
Common questions
Is the payment reduction the same as interest saved?
No. A payment includes principal and interest, and its amount depends on the repayment schedule. Compare interest costs and the ending balance separately to understand what the payment difference represents.
Can you tell me the exact break-even date now?
A reliable estimate needs the lender’s payout, new financing terms and a defined comparison method. Future rate or timing changes can alter the result. We can first identify the information required for your case.
Apply this to your mortgage plans
Tell me your goal and timing. Your initial consultation with me is free. Financing costs and any applicable fees are reviewed separately.
A rate review starts a conversation. Lender approval and pricing depend on your application, property and supporting information.
Continue your planning
Sources and further reading
- FCAC guidance on breaking a mortgage contract
- FCAC guidance on terms and amortization
- FCAC guidance on mortgage interest
Reviewed November 17, 2026. These sources explain the underlying rules and processes. The preparation questions help frame a personal review. Lender requirements can vary.
